In doing my research regarding the genesis of Love Never dies, I've learned that Andrew Lloyd Webber has attempted to get the project off the ground several times. Can you imagine the pressure of writing a sequel to the most successful show in the history of musical theatre? Must have been unbearable. So, did it live up to the insane expectations? Not for me.
Beginning with good, the orchestrations are beautiful. Though the music is overly repetitive at times, I didn't mind because it's entrancing. Stunningly unique score that fits the show perfectly. Continuing, the cast is top-shelf. My love for Ramin and Sierra is well-documented, but everyone more than pulls their weight. Last bit of good, though along the lines of the previous statement, the acting is wonderful. This may seem obvious to some, but occasionally, with a cast recording, it's difficult to emotionally invest in the story. The lack of visuals and environment hinders. Not an issue in this instance. Every beat of story shows through.
Speaking of story, it's certainly the biggest problem. One would think, with the meticulous care taken in other areas, that the most important element would be brilliantly crafted. While I won't ruin it for you, I knew how everything was going to play out within the first fifteen minutes. On top of the ridiculous level of predictability, there are holes in the story big enough to drive a truck of inconsistencies through. While there are certainly a few sparks of genius, most of the story greatly detracts from any real enjoyment of the piece.
