This recording is unique, in that both brilliance and mediocrity are on prominent display. There's no disputing that Claude-Michel Schonberg and Alain Boublil created a masterpiece with this work. Music, lyrics, and story are among the greatest in the history of musical theatre. My problem lies more with the interpretation of this particular offering. To begin, though this is hard for me to say because of my love for her, I think Patti Lupone was terribly miscast as Fantine. Playing her as a weak victim of circumstance does the character a great disservice. It's also unfortunate that Patti's incredible voice never realizes its full potential.Why are significant portions of the show missing? Failure to include pivotal scenes and songs is not only unnecessary, but may cause confusion. If a complete version exists, I hope it sees release someday.
Big thumbs up to the bare orchestration. In stark contrast to the lushness of the 10th Anniversary Concert, a gritty reality and simplicity is found. Continuing in a positive light, the original lyrics are extraordinary, and make one question why they were ever rewritten. With the exception of the above mention, this cast is perfect.
The first in a long line of English Les Miserables recordings, The Original London Cast is my pick for all-around standout.
No comments:
Post a Comment